Online dating can be a minefield. So when best friends Sutton Myers and Cole Hansen head off to different colleges, they decide to help each other sort through the choices. Sutton and Cole give each other access to their Matchbox accounts and agree to go out with whoever the other person chooses.

They learn pretty quickly that they don’t really know each other quite as well as they thought. As they each suffer through a series of awkward, mismatched dates, they start to wonder if the other person is sabotaging them. Or could it be that their only perfect match is someone they already care about?